RFE
27 Jun 2025, 18:09 GMT+10
Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khameneisabsencefrom public view during the Israel-Iran war could become a defining moment for his leadership and the Islamic republics future.
While Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was a constant presence -- issuing daily statements and projecting resolve -- Khamenei, Irans commander-in-chief, was largely unseen, releasing only two video messages during the conflict, one almost certainly filmed in a bunker.
As a third video messagesurfacedafter the ceasefire, debate over the impact of his wartime conduct has sharpened among experts and the Iranian public.
Khameneis disappearance was not simply a matter of leadership style; it was directly fueled by credible reports that he was at the top of Israels hit list.
SEE ALSO:
12 Days Of War: Takeaways From The Israel-Iran Conflict
Israeli Defense Minister Israel Katz publicly confirmed that Israel actively sought to assassinate the Iranian supreme leader during the conflict, but couldn't as he went very deep underground, meaning there was no operational opportunity.
The threat was so acute, Khamenei reportedly suspended all electronic communication and relied only on trusted aides. The New York Times reported he even designated a line of succession in case he was killed.
This extraordinary level of threat and Khameneis response shaped perceptions of his leadership.
Ayatollah Khamenei was responsible for both bringing this catastrophe upon his regime and saving it at a moment of peril, Ali Vaez, the director of the Iran program at the International Crisis Group, told RFE/RL.
The opening Israeli strike eliminated an echelon of Irans military command and exposed serious structural weaknesses within Irans leadership and security apparatus, Vaez said.
These setbacks, compounded by damage to Irans missile arsenal, nuclear program, and regional proxies, have left the Islamic republics strategic doctrine in disarray.
While Khamenei survived the conflict, both physically and politically, his legacy is ruinous for the country, Vaez argued.
SEE ALSO:
Is Military Intervention In Iran A Viable Path To Regime Change?
Yet, some see nuances in Khameneis crisis management.
Raz Zimmt, the director of the Iran and the Shiite Axis research program at the Tel Aviv-based Institute for National Security Studies (INSS), noted that despite the initial shock and the loss of senior commanders, Khamenei managed to appoint successors rapidly -- an organizational feat that is not that easy, especially given the scale of those losses.
Despite the surprise, despite the shock, which certainly increased his paranoia, I think he actually managed to name successors in less than 24 hours, Zimmt told RFE/RL.
This ability to maintain control in the face of chaos, he argued, has temporarily insulated Khamenei from direct challenges to his authority.
It will be even more difficult to question his authority in the near future, mostly due to the fact that hes surrounded by less experienced commanders.
The episode, however, has further elevated the role of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC).
Vaez pointed out that every major external shock to the Islamic republic has historically contributed to the expansion of the IRGCs role in the system.
The IRGC has emerged from the crisis as the political establishments backbone, rapidly filling critical command gaps and positioning itself as the indispensable institution for the Islamic republics survival.
Zimmt concurred, arguing, I dont see anyone else who can replace the Revolutionary Guards as the main element within the Iranian elite who can provide security and back the existence of the regime.
Interactive: This Is How Iran Is Ruled
Still, the wars strategic costs are likely to raise difficult questions in the months ahead concerning the inability of Iran to preserve its deterrence vis-a-vis Israel and United States.
However, he adds, I think that as long as [Khamenei] is there, and as long as there is no reason for him to retire, the IRGC will just support him and then prepare for the day after his succession.
Both experts agree that while a coup is unlikely in the short term, the IRGCs influence is only set to grow, especially as Khameneis advanced age brings succession questions to the fore.
Vaez warns that the IRGC is inching closer to considering the clerical leadership more as a liability than an asset.
Meanwhile, Zimmt sees no sign of imminent change in Irans strategic direction, neither under Khamenei nor under his successor, which he said would suit the IRGC just fine.
So, while immediate challenges to Khameneis rule are unlikely, the IRGCs centrality has only increased because of the war with Israel, which set in motion questions and power struggles that will shape the future of the Islamic republic.
Get a daily dose of New York Telegraph news through our daily email, its complimentary and keeps you fully up to date with world and business news as well.
Publish news of your business, community or sports group, personnel appointments, major event and more by submitting a news release to New York Telegraph.
More InformationNEW YORK CITY, New York: New York City's financial markets reacted sharply this week as shares of local banks and real estate investment...
SEATTLE, Washington: U.S. coffee company Starbucks has said it is not planning to sell all of its business in China, even though a...
NEW YORK, New York - U.S. stocks surged on Thursday, with Wall Street's major indexes climbing nearly 1 percent as investor optimism...
NEW YORK, U.S.: Two giants of the early internet job search era—CareerBuilder and Monster—have formally filed for bankruptcy protection,...
LONDON, U.K.: Amazon has once again been rated the worst major UK grocery retailer by its suppliers when it comes to following fair...
LONDON/NEW YORK/CHICAGO: In suburban Chicago, just 15 minutes from O'Hare International Airport, a small customs brokerage quietly...
NEW YORK CITY, New York: New York City's financial markets reacted sharply this week as shares of local banks and real estate investment...
NEW YORK, U.S.: Two giants of the early internet job search era—CareerBuilder and Monster—have formally filed for bankruptcy protection,...
NEW YORK, U.S.: A political newcomer is on the verge of reshaping New York City politics. Zohran Mamdani, a 33-year-old state assemblyman...
NEW YORK CITY, New York: The escalation of conflict between Israel and Iran, compounded by the United States' military involvement,...
LONDON/NEW YORK/CHICAGO: In suburban Chicago, just 15 minutes from O'Hare International Airport, a small customs brokerage quietly...
MADISON, Wisconsin: Tens of millions of residents across the Midwest and East Coast faced dangerously high temperatures over the weekend...